A Mullet Of Christmas Romance Not Even Until The Middle, Then Hockey Romance In The Back. In total, this book absolutely works. Now, it won’t be for the “clean” / “sweet” crowd – if the fucking cussing in Chapter 2 doesn’t throw you out, the habanero spice not much later will. But for those who don’t mind a dude that cusses like a … well, an athlete… and who *want* the spice… hey, this may be exactly what you’re after as a whole book.
Now, there are reasons I titled this book a “mullet” and I mention that it works “as a whole book”. And those reasons all center around the fact that it feels almost like a merger between a 140 ish page Christmas novella and a 180 ish page Hockey short novel, with enough of a merger that it works… but also because of what it actually is, isn’t going to be fully want many (either direction, Christmas or Hockey) really want.
Now, some people can absolutely rock mullets and absolutely make them work. Here, I think Sullivan actually does a reasonable job of exactly that. maybe not quite a David Bowie mullet, but certainly a Billy Ray Cyrus Achy Breaky Heart mullet. (Which, to be clear, as a not-quite-10yo Son of the South in that era, *all* of my friends wanted to sport that particular mullet there for a minute.)
Basically, as long as you come into this book expecting a spicy romance more generally, I think you’re going to enjoy this book. If you come in expecting it to be 100% either one of its main components… you’re likely not going to enjoy it as much. I do think you’ll enjoy whichever component you’re here for, and based on the cover I expect that will be the Christmas “novella” that doesn’t quite hit the 50% mark of this text. But if Hockey romance isn’t your thing… that just-over-half won’t be *as* compelling to you.
All I ask here is that if this review makes you want to read this book, go in knowing what I’ve told you… and don’t 1 star or 2 star this tale because it has cussing or because it is a bit spicy or because it isn’t fully one trope or another. Judge it, as I have, on its totality, and still discuss in your review what issues you may have had with it. PLEASE discuss the cussing and the spice, if you enjoyed it or if you had a problem with it. Not everyone will see this review. But don’t 1 or 2 star the book just because of those things.
Overall, a solid enough mullet of a romance story, and I for one will be continuing to read Ms. Sullivan’s books to see where she goes next.
Recommended.
This review of You Make It Feel Like Christmas by Sophie Sullivan was originally written on September 24, 2025.