Slow Paced Yet Intriguing, Not Sure That Twist Lands As Intended. This is one of those slower paced books where there is enough here to keep you invested – and Sheinmel certainly drops some bombs at exactly the right time when maybe you’re becoming slightly less invested. Also a great shortish (sub 300 page) read, but a slower one where the scenes play out more akin to the pace one would imagine of a luxury beach resort rehab facility so much of the story is set within. Which itself works quite well.
The one thing that becomes a bit jarring is the twist, and because it is the twist I really can’t say *too* much about it here in this review other than to note that for me, the story became maybe a touch *too* weird here, or maybe it was just that the editing could have been a touch tighter to help focus the reader a touch more. *Something* just felt a touch off… but maybe that was a “me” thing. It is very possible, maybe even very likely, that I’m the idiot here and that this twist works for most people and works rather flawlessly for them. Read the book for yourself, write your own review, and feel free to tag me wherever you may see this review on your own feeds and let me know what you thought about it.
Very much recommended.
This review of Such Sheltered Lives by Alyssa Sheinmel was originally written on December 31, 2025.