More Mystery Than Romance, Still Technically Works As Both. This is one of those types of mysteries where the author tries to tap in to Agatha Christie or perhaps even the board game Clue… and hits that kind of tone relatively well, while still also playing into her cruise setting particularly well at the same time. For me, I think the absolute funniest scene was actually the introduction, but there was a decent amount of comedy throughout the book, and it very well could be one of those where another reader would find more humor in a different scene.
The romance here satisfies all known RWA/ RNA rules and is about as spicy as a warm glass of milk or so, but also feels a fair amount more told than shown – we’re *told* these characters really like each other and are falling for each other much more than we *see* it happening. It also absolutely felt, to this reader at least, like the romance element was here mostly because that is what Ferguson has made her name writing, but what she *really* wanted to write here was a cozy mystery set on a cruise ship, so she made it work reasonably well enough for both sides so that maybe she could appease existing fans and perhaps reach a few more new ones. And again, it absolutely works so far as it goes… it just isn’t one of those epic romances you’re going to remember decades from now either. (And to be fair, *few* tales are ever of that level, and for the most part romcoms are never *meant* to be that level.)
Still, as a fun, breezy, cozy mystery/ romance mashup kind of tale, this book really does work remarkably well. You’re going to be entertained for a few hours and you’re going to be able to invest so much of your attention here that you’ll be able to ignore the so-called “real” world for a while, and that, ultimately, is a sign of a solid book doing its job well.
Very much recommended.
This review of Without A Clue by Melissa Ferguson was originally written on January 18, 2026.