Scene In Service To Story. As It Should Be. With the exception of those tales where the scene is *intended* to *be* the story, scene should generally support the story of a tale and enhance it – and this book does that quite well. Yes, there are a lot of Parisian details. Holmes has been there a few times, loves it, and wanted to celebrate it in a tale – similar to so many other writers over the years, including her colleague in the Facebook group Readers Coffeehouse Kimberly Belle’s 2024 release, The Paris Widow.
Here, what we actually get is a very dark, very twisty tale of college friends who both share some very dark secrets… and are keeping other equally dark secrets from each other. This is one of those tales where there are no angels… and yet there may be a few antiheroes, depending on one’s perspective. There are aspects here that will be challenging for some readers, yet they primarily happen off screen and only the aftermath is really seen on screen at all – which can perhaps be all the more concerning for some. Yet Holmes works them with care, treading the line between hyper realism and preachiness quite well, never really veering into preachy – at least for me. Read the book for yourself and let us know what you thought of that wherever you see this review. 🙂
If you enjoy dark, twisty thrillers involving long time friends, you’re going to enjoy this book. If you enjoy being transported to Paris via books, you’re going to enjoy this book. It really does work well on both levels, even as the Parisian setting truly is in service to the story and never feels excessive or weighty at all. And if you enjoy books that are twisting until almost the very last word… yep, this is absolutely going to be your kind of book.
Very much recommended.
This review of I Know You Killed Your Husband was originally written on May 18, 2026.