Some Will Love It, Some Will Hate It, Nothing Objectively Wrong. This is one of those hyper-“progressive” Gen Z TikTok obsessed romances where how you identify with the characterization of the book itself earlier in this sentence largely tells you how much you’re going to enjoy this book, at a very broad, general level at least. Obviously everyone is different and even those generally inclined to love this book may actually hate it or vice versa, but at a review level to give you, the reader of my review, an idea of what you’re considering getting yourself into… I think it is a completely fair generalization here.
The author has “content warning” spoilers at the beginning of the book – always a mistake to my mind, as to me, they should be available on the author’s website with a message in that spot to look there. This is at least in part because these spoilers are impossible to avoid on eReaders in this location in particular, and I and at least some other readers prefer to go into books unspoiled. Now, even if one wants to try to argue back at me “but aren’t you doing exactly that in this very review”… 1) It isn’t at the front of the book at hand. No matter where you are reading this review, you actively came here away from the book. You’re not reading it immediately before reading the actual text of the story. 2) I’m also not being anywhere near as specific in my warnings as the author did, intentionally to avoid spoilers while also allowing readers of this review a chance to better determine if this book may or may not be something they are interested in spending their money and time (but I repeat myself) on.
For what it is, it works reasonably well. There’s lots of (progressive/ Gen Z/ TikTok style) banter, there’s habanero level “spice”, there’s a fair amount of “coarse language” yet also a metric shit ton of “therapy speak”, there’s some literal laugh out loud level comedy, and there is ostensibly a romance in here that will hit harder for some than for others – same as pretty well any romance book out there. In short, if you can withstand the biases and worldview of the story itself (or even actively agree with them), you’re probably going to like this romcom as much as you do a “generic romcom”. There’s nothing wrong here – but the only things that make it stick out from the pack at all are also the divisive elements that will attract some readers and repulse others, so those elements come out as a wash to my mind as an overall judgement.
Because my “subtractive method” of rating, wherein every book starts at five stars and I need specific, describable, and *preferably objective-ish* reasons to remove stars explicitly states that star removals need to be based on something resembling objective criteria, I have nothing to hang a star removal on here. Again, all flaws here are incredibly subjective and utterly dependent on the reader’s worldviews and even moods at the time of reading this book. Some will see no flaws at all, others will want to defenestrate the book almost from page 1. I hope I’ve done enough here to give you an idea which you may be, and if so I think I’ve done my job as a reviewer.
If you do choose to read this review, please do also leave a review of it in the same place you’re reading this one. I’d love to see what you thought of it, and all reviews help the author sell books – and help the author *not* sell books to those who might not enjoy the book, thus helping the author to avoid further negative reviews where possible. No matter what you think of the book and no matter how you write your review, *someone* will think you’re an idiot and buy the book to spite you and your review, and *someone* will think the author is an idiot and choose not to pick the book up to begin with. Yes, that even includes people reading this review and concluding that *I* am the idiot in question. 😉
So hey, if you’re all about the progressive/ Gen Z / Tiktok / therapy talk vibe… absolutely pick this book up, I really do think you’ll enjoy it. If you’re not completely opposed to those things, pick this book up and give it a try. I think it is at least plausible that you’ll like it. If you’re more solidly/ completely opposed to those things… maybe just skip this one and avoid the headache. There are other books out there more your style, and I can help you find some of those too. 🙂
Recommended.
This review of Well Actually by Mazey Eddings was originally written on August 3, 2025.