Quite Possibly Walker’s Best Yet. I’ve been reading Walker’s books for several years now, finding him with An Unfinished Journey, which was apparently his next book after the Red Mountain saga. Because of my own reading schedule – 90% of which, including Unfinished Journey and every other book from Walker I’ve read, including this one, is Advance Review Copy based – I haven’t had a chance to go back and read that saga yet.
With this book… I *really* need to. Not because I needed it in order to understand this book, quite the opposite. This book is *so* compelling and *so* well told that it really makes you feel for Mr. Otis Till and all that he has gone through – stuff that apparently is largely history by the beginning of the Red Mountain books, as this is his “origin” story and apparently he is a key player in the rest of the saga.
Told in a dual timeline manner with a touch of the supernatural/ magical realism, this is one of those books that uses those components well enough that even people who claim to not like any book that uses them – and yes, I’ve seen some of those types of readers over the years – shouldn’t have any difficulty with this book and indeed, I would even go so far as to say that if you allow yourself to miss this book because of your own hangups on those types of issues, you’re doing yourself a great disservice and missing out on a truly terrific book.
This is one of those tales that so very many men can relate to – the same type of story that made The Greatest Showman so truly spectacular. A man struggling to attain his life’s desires, finding it… and finding what really matters after all. Many of us have either been there or are somewhere along that path and can identify all too well with these desires, and Walker captures that struggle across the decades *perfectly*.
And yet there is more than enough here for female readers as well, as we see how Till first meets the love of his life and how she shapes the life they lead together across all the years they have left together… and then some.
Those looking for ghost pepper level spice won’t find that here, but also those looking for no more spice than a warm glass of milk may get quite red in the cheeks at times, or perhaps even get the vapors. There is nothing here that I would hesitate at all to put in front of a mid-teen or so, though it is likely a bit much for those younger than that. (To be fair, it is also one that those younger than that won’t be able to relate to as much either, but most any adult should be able to relate all too well to.)
Truly quite likely Walker at his absolute best to date, this is one that both makes me want to go back and read the Red Mountain Saga… and hope that there are more books in this particular series forthcoming.
Very much recommended.
This review of Before We Say Goodbye by Boo Walker was originally written on August 28, 2025.