Noir Thriller Blend Legal Thriller Reminiscent of Early Grisham. I think the most recent of John Grisham’s books I’ve read was Bleachers, and that was *far* from a legal thriller of any form. But I read a lot of his earlier works (The Firm, The Chamber, The Runaway Jury, The Pelican Brief, etc) many years ago, and here Bell brings to mind a question of “What if Grisham had taken a more noir tone with those books?” I honestly think the answer to that question is that you’d get something remarkably similar to what Bell has created here.
If you’re more a fan of small town / low stress tales… this one isn’t for you. If you prefer spice levels akin to a warm glass of milk… you’re gonna get the vapors if you read this book, as its spice level is more akin to a jalapeno or so. Spicy enough to feel, without necessarily making your nose run like Niagara Falls.
Indeed, another decent comparison here – without the sheer brutality of that book – is Tom Clancy’s Without Remorse, where both romance and thriller elements combine to make the tale as strong as it is, and with both thriller and romance elements being essential to the overall tale.
Except that, to be clear, this is no White Knight hero the way even John Clark is portrayed as. Bell went to great lengths to use a normal guy in a normal (ish) job as his central character here, and he does a great job of sticking to that ideal throughout this. So yes, our main guy is going to make mistakes. Things are going to be confusing and scary and awesome and nearly surreal at times… but that’s because *life* is all of those things at times, and Bell is committed to showing at least elements of all of this.
Overall a solid tale within its type that bends and breaks enough conventions or even rules as to be refreshing, while at the same time conforming to enough of them to be comfortable for fans of its types of tale.
Very much recommended.
This review of What She’s Hiding by Art Bell was originally written on March 9, 2025.